Unnecessary antibiotic prescriptions may do more than accelerate antimicrobial resistance: They can expose patients to avoidable side effects and undermine trust between clinicians and patients. In commentary accompanying findings on antibiotic misuse, Professor Linder argued that doctors should focus on whether a prescription is likely to help or harm the individual patient, while Thorpe and colleagues called for better communication to understand why patients may misrepresent symptoms or seek antibiotics.
The risks of unnecessary antibiotics
Given the scale of the deception, the findings also raise concerns that illicitly obtained antibiotics could contribute to the rise in antibiotic-resistant infections. The World Health Organization says misuse and overuse of antibiotics facilitate the development and spread of drug resistance.
This week, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention announced that drug-resistant bacteria and fungi cause 9.7 million infections and 50,800 deaths in the United States each year, according to its latest report on the threat of antimicrobial resistance.
In an accompanying commentary, Linder said an even more worrying outcome could be a “deterioration of trust” between clinicians and patients. Linder acknowledged that drug resistance was a concern but said that, for an individual patient, the development of resistance was “probably irrelevant” in most clinical situations.
Instead, Linder said doctors should ask: “Is this prescription likely to help the patient or is it likely to harm the patient?” In many cases, the greater concern is that the patient could be harmed. Unnecessary antibiotics offer no benefit while posing risks that include adverse events, allergic reactions, and disruption of the healthy microbiome. They can also create opportunities for opportunistic pathogens such as Clostridioides difficile, which the CDC classifies as a “significant threat” in its newly updated Antimicrobial Resistance Threat Report.
Antibiotic prescriptions and medical trust
“Prescribing antibiotics for diagnoses for which these antibiotics are not appropriate is medically wrong and may itself be considered a form of dishonesty or a lie primarily to reassure the patient,” Linder wrote.
He argued that dishonesty is corrosive, citing the philosopher Sisera Bok, who has written extensively about lying, including deception used to obtain antibiotics. In 1978, Bok noted that antibiotics “are sometimes used as placebos” and that many parents “have come to believe that they must request a prescription for an antibiotic every time their child has a fever or cold.” Bok argued that these “dishonest practices” threaten “the entire medical establishment” when clinicians prescribe drugs likely to cause more harm than good.
Linder concluded by reminding readers that “a physician’s duty is to act in the patient’s best interest, even if the patient wants us to do something different, even if the patient doesn’t like it, or even if the patient is lying about his symptoms.”
Improving communication about antibiotics
Thorpe and colleagues called for more attention to the reasons patients lie in the first place. They concluded that “strategies to improve communication about antibiotics are needed to address patient concerns, support understanding of appropriate antibiotic use, and strengthen the patient-physician relationship.”
Source: arstechnica.com


