San Diego has rejected a proposal involving Ubiquia “smart street lights” equipped with Flock Safety’s AI-powered automatic license plate reader (ALPR) technology. The decision came as police representatives told the City Council that vehicle thefts have fallen by 20 percent since 2023 and that Flock cameras helped recover 689 stolen vehicles.
San Diego rejects proposed smart street-light camera system
The vote represents a sharp change from three years ago, when the City Council approved the program. The city’s rejection covered Ubiquia’s so-called “smart street lights,” which were designed to work with Flock’s ALPR software. Ubiquia and Flock had partnered to provide the technology to police departments.
The decision marks the second time in less than a decade that San Diego has experimented with and ultimately rejected this type of technology.
San Diego previously purchased thousands of smart street-light systems from GE Current. The administration of the city’s previous mayor shut down those systems in 2020. Ubiquia later acquired CityIQ, developed a smart-city platform, partnered with Flock, and—with police support—proposed installing 500 new cameras in 2023.
Privacy concerns shaped the debate
At the time, San Diego’s Privacy Advisory Commission, a local watchdog body, urged the City Council to reject the plan. Pega Parsi, one of the commission’s members, said she now feels “vindicated.” Parsi described her reaction on LinkedIn.
“A reminder to all cities, agencies, and agencies: If you establish an advisory board of experts, listen to it,” she wrote. “Actually, listen seriously. It’s cheaper than learning the hard way. Try harder.”
Secure Justice, an Oakland-based advocacy group that studies and monitors Flock deployments across the country, expressed a similar view.
“We have recorded at least 513 [Flock] terminations,” according to the group’s tracker. “It’s over in red and blue states, big cities and small cities. It’s clear that Americans don’t consent to the government tracking them as we go about our daily lives,” Brian Hofer, the group’s executive director, told Ars in an email.
Source: arstechnica.com


