When Kwabena Boahene Asare joined a skin-cancer laboratory at Dartmouth College in 2021, the first-year undergraduate expected to gain valuable research experience. Instead, he initially felt overwhelmed and out of place. Asare was the only undergraduate—and the only Black person—in a lab alongside an experienced senior researcher. Although his mentors and colleagues supported him, he interpreted his distress as evidence that he did not belong in research. His experience reflects a broader debate over “impostor syndrome”: whether it is an individual flaw to overcome or a natural response to demanding, exclusionary environments.
“There was a steep learning curve,” Asare says. He was also a first-generation student from Ghana surrounded by colleagues who did not share his background.
Impostor syndrome is commonly described as the fear that, despite objective accomplishments, a person is less competent or knowledgeable than others believe. But organizational psychologists say that what is often called impostor syndrome can also be a response to difficult circumstances and ambitious goals.
Impostor syndrome can reflect systemic bias and exclusion in the workplace, particularly for people from underrepresented groups, including women, says Ruchika Malhotra, an inclusion strategist and founder of Candor, a workplace-consulting firm in Seattle, Washington. The firm advises organizations on building diverse teams and inclusive cultures. A study conducted at a US university found that women working in scientific fields, where intellectual talent is especially valued, were more likely than their male colleagues to feel like impostors.1
Malhotra says that much of the discussion around impostor syndrome pathologizes healthy self-doubt and places responsibility on individuals rather than on the environments that exclude and marginalize them. “A lot of the ways things have been said have not been constructive,” she says.
Although impostor syndrome can have harmful effects, it can also be useful in some situations. It can encourage people to prepare more thoroughly and concentrate, particularly when they are facing a long list of tasks.
“Impostor thinking is like a superpower when things get really difficult,” says Basima Tewfik, an organizational psychologist at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Cambridge who studies impostor syndrome.
Asare says that his experience prompted him to reflect on why he wanted to become a researcher. It also made him more aware of his resilience, the areas in which he needed to improve and when to ask for help. That awareness made him more empathetic and better able to support young students and researchers who feel out of place.
“That became my strength,” Asare says. He is now a researcher and consultant in oncology at Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center in Lebanon, New Hampshire.
An imprecise concept
Impostor syndrome was first described as the “impostor phenomenon” in a 1978 paper about high-achieving women.2 The paper was co-authored by psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes, who were both at Georgia State University in Atlanta at the time. They wrote that people experiencing the phenomenon “continue to have a strong belief that they are not intelligent, and are convinced that they are, in fact, deceiving those who think they are not.”
In the decades since, the impostor phenomenon has become known as a syndrome, even though it is not a medical diagnosis or classified as a mental illness. Reviews published in 2023 suggested that approximately 70% of people feel at some point in their lives that their accomplishments are undeserved.3 These feelings might be especially common in academia: a 2012 study found that 82% of graduate students experienced at least some degree of impostor syndrome.4
This pattern of thinking often affects high achievers and has been associated with lower job satisfaction, poorer performance and burnout. Some studies, including the 2012 paper, suggest that impostor syndrome primarily affects women and other groups underrepresented in academia. Other research argues that it arises in particular situations rather than being linked to specific groups. Relatively little research has examined whether commonly recommended strategies—such as listing accomplishments or accepting compliments—are effective.
Impostor syndrome has become a popular catchphrase, inspiring articles, books and courses about what it is and how to overcome it. But its definition varies widely in the scientific literature, creating uncertainty about what the phenomenon actually is and how it affects people, Tewfik says.
“People explain this phenomenon in different ways,” she says. Tewfik adds that the loose definition can make it difficult to distinguish impostor syndrome, which involves assumptions about what other people think of you, from occasional self-doubt, which focuses on a person’s own abilities.
Much of the research also relies on measures that make impostor syndrome difficult to distinguish from other psychological patterns, such as negative affectivity—a personality trait associated with a tendency to experience negative emotions including fear and anxiety. This overlap could help explain why many studies report only negative outcomes, such as a lack of career planning and reduced motivation to pursue leadership roles.5 “What we’ve been studying may actually be more like fear,” Tewfik says.
Thomas Chamorro-Premuzic, an organizational psychologist at University College London, says this negative framing is reinforced by workplaces—including academic institutions—that place too much emphasis on confidence. One of the 2024 studies found that workers who displayed confidence were perceived as more competent and dominant, regardless of their actual ability.6
When impostor syndrome prevents someone from working or forming relationships, it is usually a symptom of a deeper problem or clinical condition, such as an anxiety disorder. But feeling that you will be exposed as a fraud before giving a major presentation can instead indicate that you are being challenged or working outside your comfort zone, Chamorro-Premuzic says.
“There’s a very healthy degree out there somewhere that we’re not evaluating,” he says.
For scientists, impostor thinking can be a by-product of critical thinking and a healthy degree of scepticism, says Samantha Sutton, an independent career coach for scientists in Boston, Massachusetts. She says it is often a natural response to working in a high-achieving, competitive environment or pursuing ambitious goals, and should be normalized rather than treated as a problem to eliminate.
“If you’re going to face something big, you should be scared,” Sutton says. Her clients are often relieved when she tells them they do not need to achieve complete confidence before taking a step towards their goals. “They realize there’s nothing wrong with it,” she says.
Source: www.nature.com


