People who consumed the highest amounts of low- and zero-calorie sweeteners experienced faster declines in memory and thinking skills over approximately eight years than those who consumed the least, according to research published in Neurology, the medical journal of the American Academy of Neurology. The association was especially strong among people with diabetes, although the observational study does not prove that sweeteners cause brain damage or memory loss.
The study examined seven sweeteners commonly used in foods and drinks: aspartame, saccharin, acesulfame K, erythritol, xylitol, sorbitol and tagatose. These ingredients are often found in ultra-processed products such as diet sodas, flavored waters, energy drinks, yogurt and low-calorie desserts. Some are also sold separately for use in foods and beverages.
“Low- or zero-calorie sweeteners are often considered healthy alternatives to sugar, but our findings suggest that certain sweeteners may have long-term negative effects on brain health,” said study author Claudia Kimie Suemoto, MD, PhD, of the University of São Paulo in Brazil.
However, the results show an association rather than proven causation. The researchers could not conclude that consuming these sweeteners directly damages the brain or causes memory loss.
Study followed nearly 13,000 adults for eight years
Researchers analyzed data from 12,772 adults in Brazil to investigate whether sugar-substitute consumption was associated with cognitive health. Participants were 52 years old on average when the study began and were followed for approximately eight years.
At the start of the study, participants completed a detailed dietary questionnaire about the foods and drinks they had consumed during the previous year. Researchers used the responses to estimate each person’s daily intake of the seven sweeteners.
The participants were divided into three groups according to their estimated sweetener consumption. The lowest-intake group consumed an average of 20 milligrams per day (mg/day), while the highest-intake group consumed an average of 191 mg/day. For comparison, 191 milligrams of aspartame is approximately the amount found in one can of diet soda.
Sorbitol had the highest average intake among the seven sweeteners, at 64 mg/day. Sorbitol is a sugar alcohol, a category of sweeteners that provides sweetness and is commonly used as a sugar substitute.
Participants completed cognitive assessments at three points: at the beginning, middle and end of the study. The tests measured abilities important to everyday mental functioning, including memory, language and the speed at which the brain processes information.
The researchers assessed verbal fluency, or the ability to quickly retrieve and produce words, as well as working memory, which allows people to temporarily retain and use information. They also tested word recall and processing speed to track how these abilities changed over time.
High sweetener intake was associated with 62% faster cognitive decline
The participants who consumed the most sweeteners showed significantly greater declines in cognitive performance than those who consumed the least.
After accounting for factors that can affect cognitive health, including age, gender, high blood pressure and cardiovascular disease, the researchers found that the highest-intake group experienced a 62% faster decline in overall thinking and memory skills than the lowest-intake group.
This difference corresponded to approximately 1.6 years of additional cognitive aging over the study period. The estimate refers to performance on cognitive tests, not a direct measurement of biological brain aging.
Moderate intake was also associated with a measurable difference. Participants in the middle-intake group experienced a 35% faster decline than those in the lowest-intake group, corresponding to approximately 1.3 years of additional cognitive aging.
These findings do not mean that everyone who consumes artificial sweeteners will develop memory problems. They describe differences in cognitive-test performance between groups.
Stronger associations among adults under 60 and people with diabetes
The association was not consistent across all age groups. Among adults younger than 60, higher sweetener intake was associated with faster declines in verbal fluency and overall cognitive performance. The researchers did not find a similar association among participants aged 60 and older.
The relationship was also stronger among people with diabetes than among those without diabetes. This finding may be particularly relevant because people with diabetes frequently use sugar substitutes to manage their sugar intake.
When the researchers examined the sweeteners individually, six of the seven substances were associated with faster declines in overall cognitive performance, particularly memory. They were aspartame, saccharin, acesulfame K, erythritol, sorbitol and xylitol.
Tagatose was the exception. In this study, researchers found no association between tagatose consumption and cognitive decline. That result does not prove that tagatose protects the brain or is necessarily safer than the other sweeteners.
What the findings mean for sugar substitutes
The results raise questions about whether replacing sugar with lower-calorie alternatives consistently provides the health benefits consumers expect, particularly when brain health is considered.
“We found an association with cognitive decline in middle-aged people, regardless of whether they have diabetes or not, and those with diabetes are more likely to use artificial sweeteners as a sugar substitute,” Suemoto said. “Further research is needed to confirm our findings and investigate whether other refined sugar substitutes such as applesauce, honey, maple syrup, and coconut sugar are effective alternatives.”
The researchers emphasized several limitations. The analysis did not include every artificial sweetener available on the market, so the findings may not apply to all sugar substitutes.
In addition, participants reported what they remembered eating and drinking. These estimates may not accurately reflect their actual sweetener consumption because people can forget foods, underestimate portion sizes or report their habits inaccurately.
The study’s observational design also means that, despite efforts to account for important health differences, other factors could help explain the relationship between sweetener intake and cognitive decline. The research cannot establish that sweeteners caused the changes in cognitive performance.
Further studies will be needed to determine whether sweeteners themselves contribute to changes in brain function, why some groups appear to be more strongly affected, and whether different sugar substitutes have different long-term effects.
The research was supported by Brazil’s Ministry of Health, the Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation, and the National Council for Scientific and Technological Development.
Source: www.sciencedaily.com


