Brain scans of adults watching films show that average brain activity can look remarkably similar in people with and without autism, even as individual responses differ substantially. A study published in JNeurosci found that this variability was especially pronounced in brain regions involved in processing social information, suggesting that research focused on group averages may overlook important differences among people with autism spectrum disorder (ASD).
The findings could help explain why autism varies so widely from person to person and may eventually support more individualized approaches to care.
Using movies to study the brain
The study was led by Dorit Kleeman and James Treer at the University of Iowa, with collaborators examining how brain activity differs between adults with and without autism.
The researchers analyzed brain-imaging data previously collected by Indiana University and the California Institute of Technology. The recordings captured brain activity while adults with and without autism watched films from several genres, including animation, action movies, romantic comedies and Hitchcockian thrillers.
Films offer researchers a way to study how the brain responds to constantly changing sights, sounds and social interactions. Unlike simpler laboratory tasks, movies present a rich mixture of information that more closely approximates the complexity of everyday experiences.
The team used the imaging data to train a computational model that linked brain activity to different elements of the films, including visual details, sounds and more abstract social information such as interactions between characters.
After training, the model accurately predicted activity across several brain systems.
Kleeman explained why this approach is useful for studying social challenges sometimes associated with autism: “The computational model allowed us to look for robust brain responses to different aspects of the complex and dynamic situations in the film.”
Individual differences hidden by group averages
The most unexpected finding emerged when the researchers compared the two groups.
At first, the results suggested relatively small differences. When brain responses were averaged across participants, the model predicted similar activity in different brain systems in adults with and without autism.
However, the picture changed when the researchers examined how much individual participants differed from others in the same group.
People with autism showed greater variability in their brain responses than participants without autism. In other words, although the overall group averages appeared similar, the responses of individual autistic participants were less alike.
This increased variability was present in nearly every brain system examined. The strongest differences appeared in the social brain system, a network of regions involved in processing social information and understanding other people.
Implications for autism research
The results raise important questions about how scientists study autism. Many approaches to understanding and supporting the condition rely heavily on comparisons between average measurements from groups of autistic and non-autistic people.
But the substantial differences in how autistic people’s brains process information could mean that these averages obscure some of the most meaningful findings.
Traer described the research team’s surprise: “We were surprised to see that the group means were similar. This result suggests that we need to focus on understanding the details of individual brain responses. How and why do they differ?”
The findings point to the potential value of studying individuals and identifying smaller groups with similar characteristics, rather than searching only for brain-activity patterns shared by all people with autism.
Dr. Kleeman said: “Identifying subgroups of ASD may help us understand the condition more precisely and develop ways to provide individually tailored support.”
The researchers plan to investigate how these differences in brain activity relate to behavioral changes associated with autism. They want to determine when and where the differences emerge, how they relate to individual characteristics and what might explain them.
Ultimately, the findings suggest that understanding autism may require looking beyond the average brain and paying close attention to the distinctive ways individuals process the world.
Source: www.sciencedaily.com


