Black holes are usually associated with violent mergers, but new theoretical research suggests that under highly unusual conditions they could also split into smaller black holes. The study examines this “pair of pants” topology using mathematical models of general relativity, higher-dimensional spacetime and modified gravity. The researchers emphasize that their work identifies when fragmentation is permitted by physical laws—not whether it would actually occur in nature.
The paper was published in Physical Review D on October 22nd. “Understanding exactly what is prohibited, what is unlikely, and what is possible when assumptions are relaxed is a central goal of this study,” the researchers wrote.
Could a black hole split in two?
The researchers investigated whether a black hole’s event horizon—the boundary beyond which not even light can escape—could divide under different cosmological conditions. Their analysis began with the familiar four-dimensional universe described by general relativity, Einstein’s theory of gravity on cosmic scales. They also examined more speculative scenarios involving higher-dimensional spacetime and modified gravity.
Modeling the dynamics of a black hole horizon, particularly one that splits apart, is extremely difficult. To simplify the problem, the researchers compared separate slices of space and time, effectively representing the fragmentation process as static snapshots from before and after the split.
In the universe described by standard four-dimensional general relativity, black holes appear almost impossible to divide. A static Schwarzschild black hole—the simplest type of black hole in this theory—faces two major obstacles.
The first is entropy, which describes the possible arrangements of energy in an isolated system. Entropy does not naturally decrease; it either remains constant or increases. A related result, first theorized by Stephen Hawking and later supported by observations of gravitational waves, is that a black hole’s horizon area cannot decrease.
As a result, splitting a static Schwarzschild black hole would violate the second law of thermodynamics.
The second obstacle is kinematic. Even if a black hole could briefly form two fragments, orbital dynamics would tend to drive those fragments back together extremely quickly, preventing a lasting separation.
Rapid rotation creates a possible loophole
The researchers identified a possible exception: a rapidly rotating black hole could, in theory, spin apart.
“This is why, in four-dimensional general relativity, a black hole isolated in empty space can only break up if it rotates at a speed very close to the maximum allowed by the theory, which we call a near-extremal black hole,” Manuel Del Piano, a theoretical physicist at the University of Southern Denmark and a co-author of the study, told Live Science in an email. “Roughly speaking, the equator of the horizon is dragged approximately horizontally at the speed of light.”
In this theoretical process, the two resulting black holes could be pushed away from one another by gravity before they had time to recombine. Under ordinary four-dimensional conditions, however, such an extreme scenario appears so restricted that, as the researchers put it, “black holes don’t wear pants.”
Fragmentation in higher-dimensional spacetime
The researchers then modeled black holes in versions of spacetime with more than four dimensions. In these models, the speed of a black hole’s rotation is no longer subject to the same limit because gravity weakens as the number of dimensions increases. A sufficiently fast-spinning black hole could therefore fragment, according to the paper.
One model treats the black hole as a “black string.” Instead of remaining spherical, it stretches across an additional dimension and becomes cylindrical or string-like. The string can then pinch at several points and break into smaller objects, forming a structure resembling a “string of beads.”
The researchers also calculated that fragmentation could become favored by entropy in a model where gravity is modified. Such a change would alter gravitational interactions in the extremely distorted environment near a black hole.
“But the debris is small,” Del Piano said. “In one of our benchmarks, a 10 solar mass black hole would prefer debris … a mass several times the Great Pyramid of Giza is squeezed into a region smaller than a proton, and the heavier the parent, the smaller the debris.”
Fragmentation may also be more likely if a black hole has a “bumpy horizon.” In this scenario, the black hole is surrounded by a dense blanket or shroud of exotic matter that behaves as a single, massive quantum entity. The material’s superfluidity could produce unusual vortices that eventually cause the black hole to divide into multiple smaller objects.
What an observer would detect could depend on the number of dimensions and on whether the observer intersects the relevant “brane” or dimensional slice. The apparent result could be a reduction in the black hole’s size, direct fragmentation, or only indirect gravitational effects.
Small primordial black holes may be more vulnerable
The researchers predict that smaller black holes, including hypothetical primordial black holes formed shortly after the Big Bang, would be more likely to fragment than much larger astrophysical black holes, such as those at the centers of galaxies.
“Overall, small black holes, such as the primordial black holes from the early universe, are expected to be the most prone to fragmentation,” Del Piano told Live Science.
Gamma-ray telescopes and gravitational-wave observatories might eventually find signals consistent with the breakup of small black holes. However, the researchers say it is unclear what those signals would look like and whether the process occurs at all.
“There is one important caveat: our analysis shows when splitting is allowed by entropy and conservation laws, not what actually happens,” Del Piano said. “As we wrote in our paper, shattered glass has higher entropy than intact glass, but glass does not shatter on its own. Solving this problem requires full dynamic simulation, and this is a natural next step.”
The study is cited as: Cacciapaglia, G., Del Piano, M., Sannino, F., Vellucci, V. (2026). “When a black hole allows pants topology.” Physical Review D, 114(8).
Source: www.livescience.com


