After more than 40 years of searching, physicists at CERN have found evidence of an exceptionally rare particle decay that occurs only about once in every 10 billion beauty particles. The result, achieved by the upgraded LHCb experiment at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), could give researchers a sensitive new way to investigate unknown particles and forces beyond the Standard Model.
Why rare particle decays matter
The evidence comes from the LHCb experiment, which studies particles containing beauty quarks. Researchers at the University of Manchester played a major role in the international effort, contributing technologies that made the measurement possible.
The process, known as “Bd to mu mu,” has a statistical significance of 3.2 sigma. That is sufficient to be described as evidence, but physicists generally require a significance of 5 sigma before formally declaring a discovery. The result therefore marks a major milestone in a search that has continued for more than four decades, while leaving room for further confirmation with additional data.
Studying this decay could also provide a stringent test of the Standard Model, the leading framework for describing fundamental particles and their interactions. Precise measurements may reveal small differences between theoretical predictions and observations, potentially pointing to physics beyond the current theory.
Beauty quarks are heavier relatives of the up and down quarks that make up most ordinary matter. Collisions in the LHC produce vast numbers of beauty quarks, but they exist for only about 1.5 trillionths of a second before decaying into other particles.
These transformations allow scientists to investigate the effects of particles that cannot be observed directly in a collider. Measuring how frequently different decays occur can expose unexpected contributions from unknown particles or forces.
Particularly rare decays are especially valuable because their predicted rates can be highly sensitive to new physics. Even a small discrepancy between the expected and observed rate may provide an important clue.
A decay seen only once in 10 billion particles
In the newly observed process, a particle containing a beauty quark decays into two muons. Muons are heavier relatives of electrons.
Theoretical predictions indicate that this decay should happen only once in every 10 billion beauty particles. Despite decades of research, no individual experiment had previously produced convincing evidence that the process occurs.
The upgraded LHCb experiment has now measured a signal with a statistical significance of 3.2 sigma. While that meets the standard for reporting evidence, the result does not yet meet the 5-sigma threshold normally used for a confirmed finding in particle physics.
Professor Chris Parkes, Head of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Manchester, led the international LHCb collaboration during the construction of its major refurbishment. He also oversaw the approval of new discoveries from the collaboration’s research.
“The improved LHCb was a major undertaking, a 15-year design and construction project involving 1,900 international members,” he said.
“The UK has made the largest national contribution to this project, pioneering new technology that has enabled today’s results to explore nature at new scales. But this is also just the beginning, and we plan to build experiments that will harness the power of the next generation of the high-luminosity LHC and explore physics at even smaller scales.”
Parkes, who was made a Fellow of the Royal Society earlier this year in recognition of his contributions to LHCb, compared the likelihood of the decay to finding a perfect romantic match among everyone on Earth on a first attempt.
“This decline is extremely unlikely. It’s about as likely as going on a romantic date and finding your perfect match among everyone on the planet on the first try.”
Advanced detector makes the measurement possible
Detecting such rare events requires instruments capable of tracking particles with extraordinary precision. One of the most important components of the upgraded LHCb experiment is its silicon pixel detector, the Vertex Locator, which was developed with significant contributions from British researchers.
The detector records the paths of particles produced in collisions. Positioned just 5 millimeters from the LHC beam, it allows researchers to determine where particles are created and where they subsequently decay.
Dr Stefano de Capua, who led construction of the detector at the University of Manchester, described the collaboration behind the technology.
“We worked with around 90 UK companies to build this detector and train the next generation of scientists and engineers on the new technology we are using. We will use these detectors to pinpoint where the cosmetic meson was created and where it decayed into two muons.”
The LHCb upgrade enables the experiment to collect data up to five times faster than before. The increased data rate, combined with improved tracking, has allowed physicists to identify events that were previously too difficult to measure reliably.
Investigating the “Zeptoverse”
Beyond establishing evidence for an exceptionally rare decay, the measurement could help scientists investigate what they call the “Zeptoverse”—the extremely small distance scale associated with the zeptometer. A zeptometer is one billionth of a billionth of a meter.
Physicists expect that studying nature at such small scales could reveal the effects of particles and forces that have not yet been detected. So far, the new measurements are consistent with the Standard Model. Researchers have not found evidence that the theory is incorrect, but increasingly precise measurements may eventually expose deviations that current experiments cannot yet resolve.
Such deviations would be significant because they could indicate where the Standard Model no longer provides a complete description of the physical world.
Professor Conor Fitzpatrick of the University of Manchester, deputy physics coordinator for the international LHCb collaboration, emphasized the importance of obtaining the long-awaited signal.
“More than 40 years of research has been carried out by physicists around the world to observe this collapse. This is a golden channel for observing the effects of new physics beyond our current knowledge.”
“The results of this experiment expand our understanding of nature at the most fundamental level. We are excited to finally confirm this elusive signal and look forward to future discoveries from our data.”
What comes next for LHCb
The upgraded LHCb experiment is expected to continue collecting data into the early 2030s. More measurements should allow physicists to determine the decay’s frequency with greater precision and establish whether the current evidence reaches the 5-sigma threshold.
Researchers are also planning another major upgrade that could increase the data-collection rate by a further factor of 10. That improvement would expand their ability to study rare particle processes and search for the effects of unknown particles at even smaller distance scales.
Professor Brian Cox, a particle physicist at the University of Manchester who was not involved in the experiment, said the result illustrates how improved scientific instruments can drive progress.
“This is an important result and a beautiful example of how science advances. We upgrade our instruments and look at nature in more detail. Sometimes we see things we don’t understand, and then we make progress. We don’t know if this progress will be incremental or truly world-changing. That’s science. LHCb is a huge scientific success.”
The experiment is funded by the Science and Technology Facilities Council, which operates within the UK Department for Research and Innovation. The UK LHCb collaboration includes scientists from 10 universities across the UK and the STFC Rutherford Appleton Institute.
The observed decays do not yet provide evidence of an unknown particle or force. They do, however, give physicists a powerful new method for searching for them. After more than 40 years of work, this elusive process is now accessible to detailed study, bringing researchers closer to testing some of the deepest questions about the nature of the universe.
Source: www.sciencedaily.com


