New results from the STAR experiment at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) provide strong evidence that collisions between relatively small oxygen nuclei can create quark-gluon plasma (QGP), an extremely hot and dense state of matter believed to have filled the universe shortly after the Big Bang. The oxygen nuclei were collided at 200 billion electron volts (GeV), a much lower energy than that used in comparable experiments at CERN’s Large Hadron Collider (LHC). The findings establish a new lower bound for the conditions under which QGP can form in this small collision system.
The results, published in Physical Review Letters, show that high-energy streams of particles lose energy as they pass through the matter created in the collisions. This phenomenon, known as jet quenching, is an important indication that a quark-gluon plasma has formed.
Scientists have previously observed jet quenching in collisions involving much larger nuclei at RHIC, a U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science User Facility that operated at Brookhaven National Laboratory from 2000 until 2026. Similar effects have also been detected in oxygen collisions at the LHC, the European particle physics laboratory.
What makes the new RHIC result particularly significant is the lower collision energy. Studying smaller nuclei at lower energies allows physicists to narrow down the conditions required to produce matter resembling that of the early universe.
“QGP is thought to be a form of matter that filled the early universe, before the protons and neutrons that make up today’s atoms were formed. Understanding its properties is essential to uncovering how the early universe evolved in the first microseconds,” said Li Yi, a physics professor at Shandong University who oversaw the STAR analysis.
“One of the most powerful ways scientists can study QGP is to identify where its signs appear. And just as important, to identify where these signs disappear,” she said.
Brookhaven Laboratory STAR physicist Rongrong Ma said that examining such small collision systems helps scientists test the limits of the phenomenon.
“This analysis pushes the limits to extreme cases, which helps us learn something about this jet quenching phenomenon and the conditions necessary for QGP to occur.”
Recreating matter from the early universe
RHIC was designed to create and study quark-gluon plasma. Traditionally, researchers have done this by accelerating gold nuclei to nearly the speed of light and colliding them.
Each gold nucleus contains 79 protons and 118 neutrons. When two nuclei collide with sufficient energy, the boundary between their protons and neutrons is effectively destroyed, releasing the quarks and gluons inside. The energy of the impact also creates thousands of additional quarks and gluons through the conversion of energy into matter, as described by Einstein’s equation E=mc2.
The result is a fleeting droplet of primordial matter. It is smaller than an atomic nucleus and survives for less than a billionth of a second before the quarks and gluons recombine into more familiar particles.
Because the substance disappears almost immediately, scientists cannot study it directly. Instead, they use detectors such as STAR to analyze the particles produced as the collision system breaks apart.
One important clue is the presence of particles that emerge with less energy than expected. Their energy loss suggests that they interacted with a dense mixture of quarks and gluons before escaping.
Researchers focus particularly on jets, narrow sprays of highly energetic particles. Jets can form when a quark or gluon from one nucleus collides with a quark or gluon from the other, producing two particle sprays that travel in opposite directions.
When these paired jets, known as “dijets,” are produced near the edge of the collision region, one jet may travel farther through the plasma than the other. Comparing the two jets allows scientists to investigate how the surrounding matter removes energy from passing particles.
Yi compared the process with firing a projectile through water.
“You can think of it like shooting a bullet through water,” Yi said. “Because of the resistance, the bullet is slowed down. This is also true for high-energy particles. When they pass through the QGP, they lose energy.”
Signs of quark-gluon plasma
For decades, RHIC experiments have found evidence of jet suppression in collisions between gold nuclei. The effect is especially pronounced for jets that travel long distances through the newly formed matter.
Scientists believe these particles lose more energy because they encounter more quarks and gluons before escaping. Jets produced near the outer boundary typically pass through less material and undergo fewer interactions.
These measurements helped establish that RHIC can produce quark-gluon plasma. Further evidence came from other observations, including the unexpected discovery that the matter created in the collisions behaves like a nearly perfect liquid.
Relatively low-energy particles produced in gold collisions were observed moving collectively in a coordinated pattern. Their behavior indicated that the plasma has very low viscosity and internal resistance.
The discovery was a major surprise when it was first made. Since then, collective flow has become another important “defining” feature of quark-gluon plasma.
Can small collisions create primordial matter?
After identifying these signatures in collisions involving large nuclei, physicists began observing similar collective motion in much smaller systems.
Experiments at the LHC and later studies at RHIC detected collective flow when small projectiles—including protons, deuterons and helium-3 nuclei—collided with much larger gold and lead nuclei. LHC researchers also observed comparable flow patterns in collisions between individual protons.
Those results raised an important question: Does the coordinated motion indicate that these very small collisions also produce quark-gluon plasma, or could another mechanism explain the observations?
Scientists needed a more definitive signal. Jet quenching is one such signal, but it had not yet been clearly observed in the smallest collision systems.
“The next natural question is whether jet quenching, another important sign of QGP formation, is seen in these very small impact systems,” Ma said. “We haven’t seen a clear signal yet, so it’s still a discussion in these small systems. We want to look for the smallest systems where we can still see a clear jet quenching signal.”
To investigate the question, the researchers studied collisions between oxygen nuclei.
An oxygen nucleus contains only eight protons and eight neutrons, making it much smaller than the gold nuclei commonly used at RHIC. Oxygen nuclei are also relatively symmetrical and spherical, which makes the geometry of the collisions easier to analyze.
“This means we can more easily look for signs of asymmetric extinction of the dijet produced near the edge of the circular interaction region during a head-on collision,” said Maowu Nie, an associate professor at Shandong University who contributed to the study.
The researchers could also compare collisions in which the oxygen nuclei struck each other directly with collisions in which they only grazed one another.
“We can also compare how the jet behaves in center-head-on collisions, where the most particles are produced and where QGP is most likely to occur, and how it behaves in collisions where two oxygen nuclei barely collide, where QGP is not expected to occur.”
Nie explained that grazing collisions can be identified because they produce far fewer particles than direct collisions.
Oxygen collisions show 20% suppression
To measure jet quenching, the researchers developed an analysis that identifies concentrated streams of high-energy particles and counts how many particles emerge above a selected energy threshold.
“Our measurements are essentially counting experiments,” said Shizhi Zhang, who conducted master’s thesis research with Yi and Nie at Shandong University and is now pursuing a Ph.D. at Yale University.
“We have an algorithm that finds parallel groups of high-energy particles, jets, and counts how many of these particles emerge above a certain energy threshold.”
Yang He, a former Ph.D. student at Shandong University who developed the analytical framework and is now studying oxygen collisions at the LHC, explained how the team determined the energy loss.
“We compare what we observe with continuous jets produced near the edges of the system, and we compare what we observe with head-on collisions with counts in off-center collisions, where we would expect to see no quenching.”
The team analyzed STAR measurements from oxygen collisions performed at RHIC in 2021 at a collision energy of 200 GeV.
The results showed that high-energy particles associated with jets were suppressed by 20%, indicating that they had lost energy while passing through the collision-produced matter.
The suppression was smaller than what physicists typically measure in gold collisions, as expected because oxygen collisions create much smaller systems. However, the effect was still strong enough to provide clear evidence that quark-gluon plasma had formed.
Comparing early-universe matter at different energies
Oxygen offers another important advantage: apart from proton-proton collisions, it is the only nuclide whose collisions have been studied at both RHIC and the LHC.
This gives researchers a rare opportunity to make an “apples-to-apples comparison” between two facilities operating at very different collision energies.
The LHC conducted its first oxygen collision in 2025. Results reported by CERN from those experiments showed both collective flow and jet quenching, providing additional indications that quark-gluon plasma can form in relatively small nuclear collisions.
However, the LHC operated at collision energies above 5,000 GeV, far higher than the 200 GeV used in the RHIC measurements.
“The higher the collision energy, the more quarks and gluons are produced, which increases the likelihood of producing a hotter, denser QGP system,” Yi said. “So if a jet quenching signal exists, it should be larger at the LHC compared to RHIC.”
Higher energies make it easier to create the hot, dense conditions needed for quark-gluon plasma. Lower-energy experiments may therefore be more useful for determining when those conditions are no longer sufficient.
By reducing both the collision energy and the size of the nuclei, physicists can approach the threshold at which the characteristic traces of primordial matter disappear.
“We are pushing the limits in two ways to explore the minimum conditions for producing QGPs, both in terms of nuclear size by observing these small oxygen-oxygen collisions and by observing data from lower collision energies. And we still see this important QGP feature, which is a unique feature of our measurements,” Ma said.
Further data may define the limits
Although RHIC has completed its operations, scientists still have additional oxygen-collision data to analyze.
During the collider’s final experimental run, researchers collected measurements using both STAR and RHIC’s newest detector, sPHENIX. The facility ceased operations on February 6, 2026, following oxygen-collision measurements recorded by both instruments.
The remaining data sets could provide further insight into how small a collision system can become, and how far its energy can fall, before quark-gluon plasma can no longer form.
Understanding these limits may help physicists reconstruct how matter behaved during the universe’s first microseconds, before quarks and gluons became bound into the protons and neutrons that make up ordinary atoms today.
The research received financial support from the DOE Office of Science, the U.S. National Science Foundation (NSF), and additional international agencies and organizations identified in the scientific publication.
The researchers also used the Open Science Grid, which receives direct support from NSF, as well as computing resources at Brookhaven Laboratory’s scientific data and computing facilities and the National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center (NERSC), a DOE Office of Science user facility at DOE’s Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.
Source: www.sciencedaily.com


