Nearly 30% of U.S. adults surveyed said they had exaggerated or fabricated symptoms to obtain antibiotics, while about a quarter of caregivers reported doing the same for their children, according to two new studies. The findings highlight how difficult it can be for clinicians to decide when antibiotics are medically necessary—and how misleading symptom reports may contribute to inappropriate prescribing.
“As clinicians, we know that patients sometimes lie,” Dr. Jeffrey Linder, a general internist, primary care clinician and researcher at Northwestern Medicine, wrote in an explanation of the survey results.
The consequences can be serious because inappropriate antibiotic use can contribute to antibiotic resistance, in which bacteria become less susceptible to drugs designed to kill them. Recent data announced by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention indicate that, in 2023, there were approximately 9.7 million infections caused by drug-resistant bacteria and fungi in the United States, an increase from the previous year. The estimated number of deaths from drug-resistant bacteria also rose from 35,000 to 50,800 over two years. Earlier estimates recorded 2.8 million people affected in 2017.
Antibiotics do not treat viral illnesses such as many colds and cases of flu. Prescribing them unnecessarily does not cure those infections and can cause side effects, including stomach and gastrointestinal problems. It also puts additional pressure on bacteria to evolve resistance and acquire new ways to evade antibiotics, including within the gut’s intestinal microbiota.
Doctors play a central role in ensuring that antibiotic prescriptions are appropriate, but part of their decision-making depends on what patients report about their symptoms. Two new studies suggest that some of those reports may be deliberately exaggerated or fabricated.
Why patients reported misleading symptoms
The first study, published Friday, October 30, in JAMA Network Open, surveyed approximately 960 adults from across the United States in January and February 2026. Participants were asked whether they had ever told a health care provider that their symptoms were worse or had lasted longer than they actually had in order to obtain antibiotics, and whether they had ever fabricated symptoms for the same reason. The survey also asked about motivations, demographics, health behaviors and beliefs.
Overall, approximately 28% of respondents said they had misrepresented their symptoms. About 26% had exaggerated existing symptoms, while 17% had fabricated symptoms. The symptoms most often misrepresented were cold-like symptoms, including fever, cough and sore throat.
About two-thirds of those who reported lying were at least moderately confident that the deception would persuade a clinician to prescribe antibiotics, and 77% said the strategy had worked at least once.
The reported motivations often included feeling very unwell, believing strongly that antibiotics would speed recovery and wanting greater control over treatment. Respondents who lied were also more likely to feel that their clinician had not taken them seriously or to agree with statements suggesting that antibiotic resistance was a hoax.
The study authors wrote that “higher antibiotic knowledge and reluctance to take antibiotics were associated with a lower likelihood of misrepresentation, meaning lying about symptoms.”
Fewer than 30% of respondents who misrepresented their symptoms said they regretted lying or taking the prescribed antibiotic. Those who did regret it cited side effects, realizing that the treatment had not helped, or believing that lying was morally wrong.
Caregivers also reported misleading symptoms
The second study was much smaller and included 236 parents and other caregivers of children and teenagers younger than 18. It asked whether caregivers had lied about a child’s symptoms to obtain antibiotics and, if so, what had motivated them.
Approximately 27% said they had lied about their child’s symptoms for that purpose, and 87% of those caregivers believed the lie had been effective at least once. Their reasons were similar to those reported by adults in the first survey.
“These findings suggest that misrepresentation of symptoms may contribute to the overuse of antibiotics in pediatric care,” the study authors concluded.
The surveys included people of different ages, demographics and locations across the United States. However, the authors noted that the respondents were not necessarily representative of the entire U.S. population. The reported prevalence of lying should therefore be considered a provisional measure to be examined in future research, rather than an unbiased population-level estimate. It is also possible that some respondents who lied did not disclose it or did not remember doing so.
Doctors remain the gatekeepers
Outpatient care accounts for most antibiotic use in the United States, but it can be difficult for physicians to determine quickly whether a patient needs antibiotics. Many bacterial infections lack rapid and reliable diagnostic tests, and outpatient appointments are often short. Doctors may also worry that they will miss an infection and allow it to worsen.
Julia Szymczak, a medical sociologist at the University of Utah School of Medicine, has previously told Live Science that clinicians may also face pressure to prescribe antibiotics. The new research adds information from adult patients and children’s caregivers.
Even when patients exaggerate symptoms or pressure clinicians for antibiotics, Linder argues that prescribers remain responsible for making the appropriate decision.
“Clinicians may interpret a patient’s maximization of symptoms or questions as a request for antibiotics, but symptoms do not determine indication; the diagnosis determines indication,” he said in a commentary.
Approximately 80% of respondents who reported faking symptoms said they received prescriptions, although the study did not track every detail of those prescribing decisions.
Linder said that doctors do not necessarily need to consider the global scale of antibiotic resistance when deciding whether an individual patient should receive a prescription. Instead, they should determine whether the treatment is likely to help or harm that patient.
“A doctor’s duty is to act in the patient’s best interests, even if the patient wants something different, even if the patient doesn’t like it, or even if the patient lies about his symptoms,” he said.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not provide medical advice.
Source: www.livescience.com


