Hope’s experience highlights both the importance and the limitations of credit scores. While the UK’s three major credit-reporting companies use broadly similar data, experts say traditional scores look backwards, can disadvantage people with little credit history and may not fully reflect whether borrowing is affordable. Artificial intelligence could help lenders assess more information, but it also raises concerns about transparency, bias and accountability.
Why credit scores do not tell the whole story
“As a nation, we are overly obsessed with credit scores,” says Funmi Olufunwa, a consumer finance lawyer and founder of financial education business Hoops Finance.
Three companies create credit scores in the UK: Experian, Equifax and TransUnion. All three work with largely the same data.
“Credit scores are backward-looking. They look at what happened in the past, so they don’t necessarily predict the future,” Olufunwa says. “But when someone tries to lend you money, they’re actually looking at what’s affordable.”
Traditional credit-scoring systems can also penalise young people who have not yet built a credit history, as well as “flimsy applicants” who have recently immigrated to the UK.
With more financial data available than ever before—and growing demand for AI to interpret it—some companies are exploring whether artificial intelligence can help lenders decide who they can safely lend to.
How AI is being used in lending
In the United States, lending decisions often depend on credit scores from FICO, which uses data from the country’s three major credit-reporting companies.
However, AI-powered finance companies Upstart and Zest AI are building businesses that give lenders additional options when assessing a customer’s creditworthiness.
“Thanks to our machine learning models that examine more than 2,500 variables, we believe we can make significantly more loans at lower prices to borrowers from all walks of life,” Upstart said in a statement.
“AI has the potential to enable lenders to analyze a broader range of information, identify patterns more quickly, and build a more individualized picture of affordability and risk for someone,” said Sarah Tucker, a mortgage expert and founder and CEO of The Mortgage Mum.
Tucker believes there is a “real opportunity to improve financial inclusion” if technology enables lenders to better understand so-called thin-file applicants, rather than simply applying increasingly strict rules.
Concerns about bias and transparency
As with most applications of AI in everyday life, the technology also raises concerns.
“Consumers need to understand what information is being used to make decisions about them, and they need to be able to object if something is wrong,” Tucker explains.
Credit scores have been controversial for decades for this very reason, says Sandra Wachter, professor of technology and regulation at the University of Oxford.
“We’re not evaluating whether past decisions were correct,” Wachter argued. She added that AI may not account for existing social inequalities that influence decisions and may simply “recreate what we’ve seen in the past.”
While companies such as Upstart and Zest AI view technology as a tool for financial inclusion, Wachter believes meaningful change requires accountability alongside automation.
She says companies need to apply existing regulations and establish new safeguards to ensure that AI does not simply perpetuate historical biases.
“Without any safeguards in place, discrimination will be reinforced, encouraged and reinforced.”
Calls for safeguards in AI credit decisions
Upstart says it is working to address the issue.
“We are investing in creating objective, automated assessments to identify bias and are incorporating those assessments into our model training process, evolving them to become even more accurate and fair over time,” the company said in a statement.
Source: www.bbc.co.uk


