The documentary’s unusual co-directing team—Nathan Fielder and Oppenheim—reflects the film’s interest in performance, sincerity, and the unstable boundary between fact and fiction. Fielder, who describes himself as a “Docuphantasist,” became friends with Elizabeth Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans, and the group eventually developed a project that follows Holmes in the period before her incarceration. Rather than retell the Theranos scandal and Holmes’ conviction, the film focuses on atmosphere, awkward encounters, and the illusion of complete transparency.
Who is playing whom?
Warning: Spoilers begin here.
Fielder and Oppenheim spend little time revisiting the Theranos collapse or the trial and conviction that followed. Those events have already been covered extensively, including in Gibney’s documentary, and are not the filmmakers’ primary concern. Instead, they pursue a mood of uncertainty. Holmes and Evans invited Fielder and the crew to stay with them for 34 days before Holmes was incarcerated, Fielder said. Given the strangeness of their first interactions, Fielder became a major on-camera presence rather than remaining an unseen documentarian.
The film’s first half can feel slow, relying heavily on footage of Fielder and Holmes staring at each other without blinking as they try to establish whether the other person is sincere. The unusual dynamic recalls the kind of staged comic exchange associated with Jimmy Fallon and Jamie Lee Curtis, who have jokingly recreated it on The Tonight Show. One extended discussion examines the difference between the words “can” and “capable,” while another considers whether Holmes understands the humor in the classic “Who’s on First?” sketch.
Fielder’s deadpan comic style is more effective in the film’s reaction shots. The comedy often comes from Holmes’ expressions, including the look on her face when she insists, with wide blue eyes, that she has never lied in her life. It is also inherently awkward to see Fielder repeatedly appear at the edge of the frame, resembling an unusually shy and persistent observer.
An illusion of transparency
Much has been made of the scene in which Evans asks Fielder to film him exercising at the gym, followed by a shower scene after the workout. Evans casually displays his nudity, moving from a side view to a frontal one. The sequence is not entirely unprecedented—HBO has presented similarly explicit material—but it remains an aggressively memorable choice.
The scene also fits the film’s recurring theme of magic and misdirection, which Fielder and Oppenheim develop throughout the documentary. On one level, the camera appears to show everything. On another, Evans’ insistence—at times almost belligerence—in answering Fielder’s questions creates only the illusion of transparency. The film’s central question is therefore not simply what viewers can see, but who is controlling the performance and what remains hidden behind it.
Source: arstechnica.com



