New York’s data center moratorium is testing whether elected officials can balance the demands of large infrastructure projects with residents’ opposition to new facilities. Activists who pushed for the pause are concerned that Gov. Kathy Hochul’s executive order does not go far enough, while lawmakers and candidates face pressure to deliver on promises made during midterm election campaigns.
Adrian Josina was encouraged when New York became the first state in the country to enact a moratorium on data center development. For the past two years, the mother of three has organized in western Genesee County to oppose a proposed 600-megawatt data center near the Tonawanda Seneca Nation reservation and a federal wildlife refuge.
Nearly four months after the moratorium’s one-year grace period began, however, Josina said she was “getting nervous.” She worries that Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul will not sign a stronger bill imposing a stricter moratorium. She also believes the state Department of Environmental Protection has not been sufficiently involved in New York’s data center evaluation process.
“I feel like she’s just trying to silence us,” Josina said of Hochul.
Data centers become a midterm election issue
Data centers have emerged as a major issue in midterm elections across the country. Politicians from both parties have pledged to regulate the facilities or pause their development. The more difficult phase begins next week, when newly elected officials must decide whether to follow through on those promises as they weigh massive infrastructure projects against residents who say they oppose data centers at all costs.
The compromises that result—and whether they can satisfy voters—could shape future data center policy. New York’s moratorium and the continued opposition from some community groups may offer early clues.
Hochul’s data center suspension
In July, just two months after rejecting the idea, Hochul signed the country’s first executive order suspending data center development. Her order represented a compromise. Several weeks earlier, the state Legislature had passed an omnibus bill that would establish a one-year moratorium across New York.
The legislation included provisions that were more aggressive than Hochul’s order, including strict limits on data center size and a requirement that the Department of Environmental Conservation conduct a comprehensive study of the environmental effects of data center operations.
Rather than signing the bill, Hochul issued her own order. The governor must sign the legislation by the end of the year, but her office says it remains under review. Hochul’s data center pause has since become a central part of the debate.
Democrat Kristen Gonzalez, one of the bill’s sponsors in the state Senate, has publicly supported Hochul’s suspension. Gonzalez said the governor’s office reached out proactively after the bill passed to help develop a moratorium that would provide more immediate relief for New Yorkers.
Source: www.wired.com


